FANDOM


Which is the better film?
Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring
ANewHope TheFellowshipOfTheRing

Each is the fourth entry chronologically, though the first in production, of an iconic film saga. Both following a hero's journey with a young protagonist from humble beginnings (Luke Skywalker/Frodo Baggins) finding himself in the possession of an item of great value that is critical in defeating the growing forces of darkness seeking to dominate the world. (The Death Star Plans/The One Ring) With the aid and insistence of a powerful but friendly wizard (Obi-Wan Kenobi/Gandalf the Grey) he goes on a journey to try and bring said item into a stronghold of the forces of good (Alderaan/Rivendell before finding himself sent to try and complete the whole task of destroying the evil faction's superweapon himself. (The Death Star/The Ring) Whilst on that journey he'd be pursued by agents of evil (Darth Vader and his Stormtroopers/The Nazgul) whilst another top-ranking ally (Grand Moff Tarkin/Saruman the White) of the Dark Lord (The Emperor/Sauron) oversees the completion of a key component of his military conquest. (The Death Star/The Army of Isengard) Along the way on his journey the protagonist picks up a number of allies including a mysterious rogue (Han Solo/Aragorn) he meets at a bar. (Chalmun's Spaceport Cantina/The Inn of the Prancing Pony) However, whilst venturing through a claustrophobic enemy stronghold (The Death Star/The Mines of Moria) the sagely mentor is lost during a battle against a powerful counterpart corrupted by the forces of darkness (Darth Vader/The Balrog Durin's Bane) before the rest of the group makes their narrow escape. After which the heroes reach a forested safe haven (Yavin IV/Lothlorien) before leaving and having to engage the forces of darkness once more spearheaded by a ferocious field commander (Darth Vader/Lurtz) during a final battle (The Battle of Yavin/The Battle of Amon Hen) where he murders a friend (Biggs Darklighter/Boromir) before being subdued by the rogue who takes him off-guard with an attack from the side. In the end the battle is won, but the heroes find their adventures to have only just begun.

Which is the better film?
 
14
 
15
 

The poll was created at 13:16 on July 6, 2013, and so far 29 people voted.